Give Feedback
HomeWorld AffairsPolitics & Opinions

Facebook Censorship

Dajjal

By Dajjal

4 months ago

RSS Feed
In October of '09,  a group of Muslims who demanded the deletion of an anti-Islamic Facebook group organized a boycott of Facebook  The blog post I wrote about their boycott is still receiving views from all over the world, long after "Qur'an Toilet Paper Roll" was deleted, recreated and deleted again.

    My involvement in Facebook resulted from a Google Alert for "Ban Islam" which linked to a post on the "Ban Islam!!" group. That post included an error which I wanted to correct.  That is how I got hooked.  I had to  register a Facebook account and join the group in order to comment on the post.  "Ban Islam!!" grew to more than 3000 members. It was a lively forum with many informative articles.  

    Then it was gone. No notice, no warning, no chance to save content; it was arbitrarily deleted March 8.  I immediately invited my friends to join the smaller, less active group "Ban Islam".   Other members invited their friends, and the group grew rapidly.  Then, when I refreshed a page after commenting, it disappeared, arbitrarily pulled down just as its larger brother had been.  The groups creator started over, and the group was deleted again the next day.

    Yes, we did bash Islam. I, for one, cursed it. I tried to concentrate on well documented and logical arguments, but almost everyone backslides occasionally.  Muslims joined our groups to comment and sometimes to debate with us.  Many of them confined their activities to the wall, posting obscenities,  suggestions  related to sexually deviant status & activities and insults.

    On February 17, two new wall posts appeared,  posted by unfamiliar persons:  "Ahmad Faris" and  "Steve Brule", who posted a list of  the administrators of  "Ban Islam!!'  followed by "they must die", linking the posts to a new Facebook Group "DELETE GROUP =  BAN ISLAM!!".   One of the members had read the wall posts and  saved  a screen shot, tagging other members with it.  In my haste, I overlooked the death  threat, concentrating on the fact that they copied our admin list.  I followed the link and saw this.

Screen shot of DELETE GROUP...
The Admin list from "Ban Islam!!" in the left sidebar.

Our Admin list as it appeared on the opposition group.
    Why list our administrators on a page demanding our deletion?  There is only one possibility: intimidation.   They later added the death threat, in a foreign language.  We followed up by reporting them to Facebook, who took no action. At the time of this writing, it is still available. The page has been edited to remove the death threat.    I would like to show you the screen shot of the threat. Unfortunately, it was stored in the group's photograph section, which was deleted with the group.

    Facebook also deleted several smaller  anti-Islamic groups with offensive titles. It appears that Facebook has acted to appease the demands of Muslim groups. Observe the size of some of them.  (Click the image for enlargement.)

Partial list of groups demanding deletion of anti-Islamic groups.

    Unfortunately, Facebook's aversion to "hate speech" seems to be  monopolar. Each item in the following list is  a link to a Facebook group which attacks Judaism or Christianity. Most of them have an obscenity in their names. Do not click on these if you are easily offended!!!!

    In protest of this evident bias, members of the deleted groups are  organizing a  three day boycott of Facebook commencing at 12:01 am March 31  through 12:01 am April 2.

Subscribe to commentsExpand all commentsRSS Subscribe to comments
Comments (7)

Anonymous
Respond Report this content 0 

By Anonymous4 months ago

Islam means COMPLETE DOMINANCE - there is NO such thing as peaceful co-existence.
ISLAM is NOT RELIGION but FULLY SELF-SERVING system of rules/acts/deeds/responses. IT HAS NOTHING TO DO W/ FREE...

Anonymous
Respond Report this content +1 

By Anonymous4 months ago

Dajjal, I didn't read the comment you're responding to, but anyone who suggest that opposition to Islam is racist is probably a racist himself, of the reverse variety.

Anonymous
Respond Report this content +1 

By Anonymous4 months ago

You may be attributing wrong motives to Facebook. No matter what they say, the fact is Muslims are so dangerous that Facebook and it's people are in danger if they allow you to speak your mind.

classicruby
Respond Report this content -1 

By classicruby4 months ago

I must say first off that I do not agree with the group Ban Islam. Nor do I agree with any of the other groups outrightly attacking a whole religion or belief system. Firstly, because much like racism groups like this target each and every person within the religion, when quite frankly your beef probably is not with EACH AND EVERY individual or sect which practices the religion.

I am all for freedom of speech: you are allowed to voice your opinions in a peaceable way that does not promote violence against any group. But that being said, children are allowed to have accounts on facebook, and as a result I think that the types of groups, and the types of "hate promo" that should be allowed on the site should be controlled with an iron fist.

I personally find these types of groups absolutely revolting. Seriously, revolting. And I find anybody who could join such a stereotype-encouraging group to be rather small minded (I apologize if I offend you by saying this- I am not trying to be insulting here). However, I think that, going beyond that issue, the bigger problem is that, if facebook is going to allow these kinds of groups on their site, they should allow ANY group representing ANY opinion on their site,regardless of what religion they are for or against.

While I will not boycott facebook, I can appreciate your outrage and frustration at being silenced while others are allowed to speak freely in the same (or far worse) range of opinions, simply because of the group you choose to target.

Last post by classicruby: Don't Call Me 'Baby'